Ionic and non-ionic: what the words mean on a cleaning data sheet
They describe the electrical charge on one end of the surfactant molecule, and nothing else. Foam, temperature, metal safety and what stays on the part are set by the finished product. The data sheet carries those on other lines, and this page says which.
Updated · Fred Shaw, Misonics
The short answer. A surfactant is the ingredient that lets water lift oil: one end of the molecule holds to water, the other to oil. Anionic, cationic, non-ionic and amphoteric describe the charge on the water end: negative, positive, none, or changing with pH. The charge decides how that one ingredient behaves beside the builders, salts and inhibitors in the drum, and how it copes with hard water. It does not decide foam, pH, temperature, metal safety or what is left on the part. Those are set by the finished product and read off the data sheet: dilution, temperature window, cycle time, pH, foaming tendency, oil handling and the rinse specification.
What a surfactant does
Oil and water do not mix. A bath of water runs over an oily part and takes nothing off it. The surfactant is the ingredient that changes that.
The molecule has two ends. One end holds to water. The other holds to oil and will not sit in water. In the tank, the oil end buries itself in the soil and the water end stays out in the bath. The soil is wrapped in a coat that water can carry; it lifts off the metal and stays in the solution instead of settling back on the part.
One end holds to water, the other to oil. That is the mechanism.
The four words on a data sheet describe the water end of that molecule, and only that.
The four words
The charge sits on the water end. Each word names one charge.
Strong on oily soil. The surfactant in soap and dishwashing liquid, which is why the word is tied to foam. In industrial cleaners it is blended, not used alone.
Holds to surfaces. Used in sanitisers and fabric conditioners, not chosen for degreasing.
The usual choice in industrial cleaners. An uncharged head does not react with the builders, salts and inhibitors in the same drum, and it tolerates hard water better than soap. Wets and lifts oil well. The word says nothing about foam.
Behaves as one or the other depending on the pH of the bath. Used in blends where the pH moves.
The word amphoteric is also used of metals, and there it means something else. On our cleaning temperature guide it describes aluminium and zinc, which both strong acid and strong alkali attack.
What the charge decides. Three things: how the ingredient tolerates hard water, how it sits beside the ionic builders and inhibitors in the same drum, and, together with everything else in the formulation, how the finished product foams. That is the formulator’s question. Choosing a cleaner for a soil is a different question, and it uses a different word.
Soil and cleaner: two words for charge, two different questions
The soil on a part is described as polar or non-polar. The surfactant in a cleaner is described as ionic or non-ionic. Both pairs are about electrical charge, so people line them up and read non-ionic as the match for non-polar. They are separate questions.
Like dissolves like sorts the soil
Cutting and hydraulic oils, greases, waxes, buffing compounds, coked carbon, drawing compounds. Water alone does not touch them. They need alkaline chemistry with surfactants, and saponifiers where there is fat to convert. Whether those surfactants are anionic or non-ionic is a formulation decision.
Mineral scale, hardness deposits, rust, oxides, heat scale, salt. They respond to acid-side chemistry and to chelants that lock up the metal ions. Surfactant is a small part of the package; some acid cleaners carry very little.
Most parts carry both families, which is why staged processes exist and one drum does not do everything. Cleaning chemistry by soil sets out what takes each soil off and which of our products carry it; the chemical compatibility matrix says what each product is cleared to touch.
What the words do not decide
Non-ionic gets read as a quality mark. It is one ingredient’s charge. Four things it is taken to promise, and what decides each.
What decides it: the whole formulation at your strength, your temperature and your soil load. Some non-ionic surfactants are chosen because they foam little; others foam freely; blends of anionic and non-ionic run quiet in a tank every day. Each of our data sheets states a foaming tendency. Read that line.
What decides it: the drum, not the surfactant. The same product can be strongly alkaline and carry ionic builders and salts. If the next step is bonding, coating or an electronic assembly, specify the residue limit and measure the final rinse.
What decides it: the pH and the inhibitor package of the finished product. Metal safety comes off the data sheet and the compatibility matrix, every time.
What decides it: the temperature window on the data sheet for the product in the tank. Some non-ionic surfactants come out of solution as the bath warms and the liquid turns cloudy; their behaviour changes and foam usually drops, which some high-temperature low-foam cleaners are built around. It is not a switch. A cloudy bath is more often emulsified oil, soil or hard-water minerals than the cloud point.
Foam in an ultrasonic tank
Cavitation needs liquid. The transducers put energy into the solution, bubbles form and collapse, and the collapse scrubs the part. Foam is air, and air absorbs the energy before it reaches the part. A tank with foam on it looks busier and cleans less.
Foam is air. Air absorbs the ultrasound instead of passing it on.
One of the most widely qualified aqueous detergents we supply, approved by Boeing, Rolls-Royce and NASA among others, carries a foaming tendency of moderate to high on its own data sheet and cleans well in ultrasonics: run inside its temperature window, degassed after make-up, filtration returns kept below the surface. Foam is managed by how the bath is run, not avoided by a word on the label.
Hard water. Soap, which is one anionic chemistry, reacts with calcium and magnesium and drops out as scum. Many synthetic anionic surfactants tolerate hardness, and formulators add water conditioners for it. Non-ionic surfactants tolerate hardness better than soap. None of this removes the water question: dissolved minerals still dry onto the part in the final rinse. Set the rinse water quality separately.
Read the data sheet: the lines that set the bath
Our technical data sheets do not use the words anionic, cationic or non-ionic. They give the lines that set a machine up and that we are held to. Read these.
| Line on the sheet | What it tells you | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Dilution | The working strength, as a percentage. | Make up to the sheet. More concentrate is not faster: it wastes chemical, drags out on every basket and loads the rinse. |
| Temperature window | The range the whole formulation is proven in. | Run inside it. It already accounts for every ingredient, including any cloud point. |
| Cycle time | How long at that strength and temperature. | Set the timer to it. Change one thing at a time. |
| pH | Which mechanism you have bought, and which metals are at risk. | Check the alloy against the compatibility matrix before the part meets the bath. |
| Foaming tendency | Stated for each product. | Judge it at your strength and temperature with real soil in the tank. Degas after make-up; keep filtration returns below the surface. |
| Oil handling | Whether the product splits oil for skimming or holds it in emulsion. | High oil load: a splitting product with a weir or skimmer, so the bath lasts. Light, intermittent soil: an emulsifying product is simpler, and the tank is dumped rather than skimmed. |
| Free-rinsing | The detergent lets go of the part in a water rinse and does not dry to a film. | A property of the formulation, stated on the sheet. |
| Water-break-free | A test result: water sheets evenly across the part, so no oily film is left (ASTM F22). | Proves there is no hydrophobic film. Says nothing about salts or particles. |
| Final-rinse conductivity | The measure of ionic residue in the final rinse, in µS/cm. | Under 50 for ultra-clean work such as oxygen service and aerospace; under 500 before coating, bonding, plating or inspection; over 500 for general cleaning. A long hot rinse also strips the corrosion inhibitor, so match the rinse to the specification. |
| Metals cleared | What the product may run on. | The compatibility matrix, every time. |
An ingredient class is not a specification. Two products can both be non-ionic and want different strengths, temperatures and cycle times. If a sheet leads with the charge and is vague about the window, notice it. Where this page and a data sheet disagree, the data sheet is right.
Related: clean is a number, on gravimetric residue, particle codes and ionic limits · cleaning temperature guide.
Our products, by soil family
These cover most of what comes through the door: three for the oily, non-polar family at different duties, and one for the other family.
AquaVantage 815 GD
Mildly alkaline, for manufacture, repair and overhaul of precision components. Rinses free to a water-break-free surface and separates oil for skimming, so the bath lasts. Its sheet states a moderate-to-high foaming tendency and a final-rinse conductivity target: the two lines a charge label does not carry.
AquaVantage 815 QR-NF
Alkaline and heavy duty: heavy greases, baked carbon and difficult residues in immersion, ultrasonic and mildly agitated systems. The same family as 815 GD at a higher duty. Use it when the precision grade has had a fair run at the right strength and temperature and the part still comes out marked.
AquaVantage 1696 GD
Near-neutral pH and non-foaming: the pair of properties the word non-ionic is wrongly taken to guarantee. Non-silicated, non-phosphated, APE and NPE free. For the metals an alkaline bath punishes, cadmium, copper and copper alloys, and for plastics and elastomers.
Descale
A phosphoric-acid concentrate. Oxides, rust, heat scale and weld spatter are the polar family and no surfactant shifts them; this works by chemical attack on the scale itself. A part carrying both families is a staged process, not one drum.
The full range is on the chemicals page; the chemical compatibility matrix says what each one is cleared to touch. Dilution, temperature, cycle time and pH come off each product’s own data sheet.
Every other word on the data sheet
The terms on our sheets and product pages, and what each one tells you.
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Surfactant | The ingredient with a water-holding end and an oil-holding end. It is what lets a water bath shift oily soil. |
| Anionic · cationic · non-ionic · amphoteric | The charge on the surfactant’s water end: negative, positive, none, or changing with pH. Describes one ingredient, nothing else. |
| Polar · non-polar | Describes the soil, not the cleaner. Non-polar is the oil and carbon family; polar is the salt, scale and oxide family. |
| Builder | Raises and holds the pH and softens the water, so the surfactant is not used up by hardness. Usually the ionic part of an alkaline cleaner. |
| Chelant · sequestrant | Locks up calcium, magnesium and dissolved metal ions so they stay in solution instead of dropping onto the part or the tank. |
| Saponifier | Converts fats and fatty oils into soluble soaps, so they wash away instead of needing to be lifted. For animal and vegetable fats, not mineral oil. |
| Emulsifier | Holds released oil in suspension in the bath. The opposite design to a splitting package, which lets the oil separate for skimming. |
| Corrosion inhibitor | Lays a protective film on the metal so the part does not flash rust between the tank, the rinse and the next stage. A long hot rinse strips it. |
| Free-rinsing | The cleaner lets go of the part in a normal water rinse rather than drying to a surfactant film. |
| Water-break-free | A test result, not a property of the cleaner. Water sheets evenly across the part, so no oily film is left. |
| Conductivity, µS/cm | How much ionic residue is left in the final rinse. Lower is cleaner. This is the number; the water-break test is not. |
| Foaming tendency | Stated on each data sheet. A property of the finished product at working conditions, managed by how the bath is run. |
Questions we are asked
What does non-ionic mean on a data sheet?
Is a non-ionic cleaner always low-foaming?
Does non-ionic mean there are no ions in the bath?
Is a non-ionic cleaner the right choice for non-polar soil?
Can I use an anionic detergent in an ultrasonic tank?
Does a non-ionic cleaner stop working above its cloud point?
Does a water-break-free surface mean the part is clean?
Where this comes from
- Strength, temperature, cycle time and pH for each product are read off its technical data sheet and safety data sheet, on the product pages.
- Which metals a product is cleared for: our chemical compatibility matrix.
- The definition of a surfactant follows the IUPAC Compendium of Chemical Terminology, entry for surfactant (surface active agent).
- The water-break test is ASTM F22, Standard Test Method for Hydrophobic Surface Films by the Water-Break Test.
- The final-rinse conductivity tiers, under 50 µS/cm for ultra-clean and under 500 for precision, are from our product technical data sheets and appear on the product pages.
- Foaming tendency is stated on each product’s technical data sheet.
- On foam falling away above the cloud point: Chaisalee and others, “Mechanism of antifoam behavior of solutions of nonionic surfactants above the cloud point”, Journal of Surfactants and Detergents, volume 6 (2003), pages 345–351.
- The foam, oil-handling and rinsing behaviour described here is our own, from bath testing and trial work on customer parts.
Read next
Which cleaning solution for which job
The product for each metal and dirt, with the strength, the temperature and the metals to keep out.
Matching the chemistry to the soil
Oil, baked carbon, paint, rust and mineral ash each come off a different way. Which chemistry takes each one off.
Why a degreaser will not touch scale
Oils need alkaline chemistry, scale needs acid, and most parts need both in turn.
Not sure which cleaner your parts want?
Tell us what is on the part, what it is made of and what happens to it next. We say which product and cycle to run, and prove it on your parts before you buy a drum.